All stories

Underdog Stories / Sports analysis & explainers

Why Do Quarterbacks Dominate the NFL MVP Award?

Why do quarterbacks dominate the NFL MVP award? Their control of each drive, plus decades of voting habits, makes historic seasons elsewhere a hard sell.

By Brett Hanson · Underdog Podcasts · November 19, 2026

Share on X
Stacey OWNS Sports

Stacey Collier had barely finished asking about Joe Burrow before the MVP talk on Stacey OWNS Sports widened to include a running back from 2012. That jump made sense.

Why do quarterbacks dominate the NFL MVP award? A quarterback can shape almost every offensive drive. He chooses where to throw and often changes the play before the snap. Voters have long tied that control to a team’s success. A great season elsewhere must clear a much higher bar.

Why does quarterback matter so much to MVP voters?

In the episode “Joe Burrow for MVP, Mets for Skubal, Spurs are Favorites,” Collier asked whether Burrow belonged at the front of the MVP discussion. Noah Urrutia said he did. Mason Vale agreed, then moved from Burrow’s passing numbers to something less tidy: how much time the Bengals’ line gave him to let a play develop.

That is the quarterback’s reach. He touches the ball on nearly every pass play and decides what happens next. He can make a receiver’s route useful or leave him running through empty space. Even on a handoff, the defense has to account for what the quarterback might do instead.

The quarterback also gets credit for work he shares. A clean pocket helps. So do receivers who get open. A defense that hands the offense good field position helps, too. Yet when all of it turns into a long scoring drive, the passer’s name sits beside the yards and touchdowns.

That credit is sometimes deserved. The passer has to read the defense and get the ball out. Still, it makes comparing positions awkward. A running back can turn a poor block into 20 yards. He cannot call for another carry whenever he likes. A receiver cannot throw himself the ball.

Collier raised that problem while talking about Seattle receiver Jaxon Smith-Njigba. He asked what the Seahawks would be without him. It is a fair MVP question. It is also one a quarterback usually gets to answer with the ball in his hands.

Who votes for the NFL MVP award?

The Associated Press picks the MVP through a panel of 50 journalists who cover the NFL. Since the 2022 season, each voter has ranked five players. First place is worth 10 points; the remaining spots are worth five, three, two and one.

There is no quarterback-only rule. A voter can put a running back first. Still, the ballot asks each person to compare jobs that barely resemble one another. How many catches equal a quarterback’s control over an offense? The award supplies no conversion chart.

Look at 2023. Lamar Jackson won with 493 points and 49 first-place votes. Christian McCaffrey finished third with 147 points, just behind quarterback Dak Prescott’s 152. McCaffrey was plainly in the race. He was nowhere near winning it.

Vale said McCaffrey’s loss made MVP feel like “a quarterback award.” That is sharper than the written rules, and much closer to what the results show. Voters can reward a player at another position. Getting enough of them to rank him above every strong quarterback is the hard part.

The vote also ends before the playoffs. Cooper Kupp’s later Super Bowl performance, for example, could add to his reputation. It could not change his ballot for the 2021 regular season.

Has the MVP award always favored quarterbacks?

Quarterbacks have a long hold on the award, though the past gives other players some room. Shaun Alexander won as a running back in 2005. LaDainian Tomlinson followed in 2006. Adrian Peterson won in 2012.

When the panel tried to recall the last non-quarterback before Peterson, Vale guessed Alexander. Collier thought that might be right. They missed Tomlinson between them. The slip is understandable: by the time of their discussion, Peterson’s win was 14 years old.

There are even defensive winners. Minnesota tackle Alan Page took MVP in 1971. New York Giants linebacker Lawrence Taylor won in 1986. No defensive player has won since Taylor.

The recent run is starker. Every AP MVP from the 2013 season through the 2025 season played quarterback. The latest completed award in that stretch went to Matthew Stafford for 2025. He edged fellow quarterback Drake Maye by five points. All 50 first-place votes went to quarterbacks.

“Ever since McCaffrey didn't win it in 2023, it's pretty much just been like, it's a quarterback award.”
— Mason Vale, on Stacey OWNS Sports

That history can influence what seems normal on a ballot, even without a rule telling voters what to do. A runner now has to beat the quarterback’s season and an old question hanging over it: if the passer drove the offense, how can someone else be its most valuable player?

How did Adrian Peterson win MVP in 2012?

Peterson gave voters an answer they could see on nearly every carry. He ran for 2,097 yards in 2012, eight yards short of Eric Dickerson’s single-season record. His Vikings went 10-6 and reached the playoffs.

The year before, Peterson had torn ligaments in his knee. He returned for the start of the 2012 season and played all 16 games. By December, defenses knew Minnesota wanted to give him the ball. He kept gaining ground anyway.

His final regular-season game against Green Bay captured the case. Peterson ran for 199 yards as Minnesota won 37-34 and secured a playoff spot. One more long run would have put Dickerson’s record within reach. The Vikings needed the win more than a record chase.

Peterson’s season made a rare argument: the back was the clearest reason his team could move the ball. He also had a huge number to put beside that argument. His 2,097 yards remain the last winning case made by a non-quarterback.

Vale brought up Peterson when Collier said the MVP conversation kept coming back to passers. The answer was correct, even if the panel needed a moment to confirm it. That pause says plenty about how seldom the exception comes around.

Why didn’t Christian McCaffrey or Cooper Kupp win?

McCaffrey’s 2023 numbers looked like a bid to break the pattern. He led the NFL with 1,459 rushing yards and 2,023 yards from scrimmage. He scored 21 touchdowns, despite sitting out San Francisco’s regular-season finale.

He won AP Offensive Player of the Year. Jackson won MVP. Their teams’ offenses used them in different ways, which makes a clean comparison impossible. McCaffrey could run between the tackles and catch a pass downfield. Jackson could decide where the play went in the first place.

Kupp made an even rarer statistical case in 2021. The Rams receiver led the league with 145 catches, 1,947 receiving yards and 16 touchdown catches. That is the receiving triple crown. Collier said Kupp should have beaten Aaron Rodgers for MVP, and Urrutia agreed.

The vote was less close than their exchange might suggest. Rodgers received 39 first-place votes. Tom Brady got 10. Kupp got one. He won Offensive Player of the Year, an award that gave his season its due without requiring voters to choose him over a quarterback.

There is a catch in that logic. Kupp needed a passer to get him the ball, and Stafford was throwing it. That does not make Kupp’s catches less impressive. It gives a voter another name to credit for the same Rams plays.

Can a non-quarterback still win NFL MVP?

Yes. Peterson proves it. The next winner will probably need a season that is easy to grasp at once: extraordinary production, a team that wins with him at its center, and no quarterback with an overwhelming case. Those are judgments, not ballot rules.

Recent seasons show how narrow the path has become. Saquon Barkley rushed for 2,005 yards in 2024 and finished third in MVP voting. Josh Allen won. In 2025, Smith-Njigba led the league with 1,793 receiving yards and won Offensive Player of the Year. Stafford won MVP.

Collier’s question about Smith-Njigba was the human version of the argument: take him away, and what remains? The ballot offers no way to run that test. It records the season the team actually played.

During the episode, the hosts joked about Patrick Mahomes appearing in the conversation. Vale supplied the punch line: “Made a couple commercials.” It was a laugh at how readily a familiar quarterback’s name can enter an MVP discussion. For a receiver, even 1,793 yards may lead to a different trophy.

The full episode of Stacey OWNS Sports is on Underdog Podcasts, with the rest of the network's shows.

People also ask

Who was the last non-quarterback to win NFL MVP?+

Adrian Peterson won the AP NFL MVP award for the 2012 season. The Minnesota Vikings running back rushed for 2,097 yards, eight short of the single-season record, and helped his team reach the playoffs. Every winner from the 2013 season through the 2025 season was a quarterback.

Has a wide receiver ever won NFL MVP?+

No wide receiver has won the AP NFL MVP award. Cooper Kupp came close enough to receive one first-place vote in 2021 after leading the league in catches, receiving yards and touchdown catches. Aaron Rodgers won that year. Kupp received AP Offensive Player of the Year instead.

What is the difference between NFL MVP and Offensive Player of the Year?+

They are separate AP awards. MVP asks voters to choose the league’s most valuable player across positions. Offensive Player of the Year honors an offensive player’s season. Christian McCaffrey won the latter in 2023, when Lamar Jackson won MVP. Cooper Kupp won it in 2021, when Aaron Rodgers took MVP.

Do playoff games count in NFL MVP voting?+

No. AP voters submit their ballots after the regular season and before the playoffs. A postseason run can change how fans remember a player’s year, but it cannot change that season’s MVP vote. That distinction matters for players such as Cooper Kupp, whose Rams reached the Super Bowl after ballots were cast.