Sometimes, the smallest unanswered question can lead somewhere you never expected. For Cynthia Stack, it started with concerns about her father’s money. But as she began digging for answers, she found herself getting closer to something far more disturbing. Then Cynthia and her son, Sean Stack, were killed. What happened between those two events would raise questions about trust, money,…

In the summer of 2019, Ina and David Steiner began experiencing a series of increasingly unsettling incidents at their home in Natick, Massachusetts.It started with something they couldn't explain. Then came strange messages, unwanted deliveries, and other disturbances that seemed too specific to be random. As the incidents continued, the Steiners found themselves trying to piece together what…

On a quiet Monday evening in May of 1994, 18-year-old Cleashindra Hall walked into her after-school job at a house on Fawcett Road in Pine Bluff, Arkansas, and there's no confirmed record of her ever walking back out. Decades later, the case remains unsolved, the file still sealed, and the man at its center has never fully explained himself. This episode discusses the disappearance of Cleashindra…

When 24-year-old Jade Benning was rushed to the hospital after spending the evening with the father of her unborn child, those closest to her believed she was suffering from a sudden medical emergency—possibly an allergic reaction. But as detectives began reconstructing the final hours of her life, that explanation began to unravel. In this episode, we explore who Jade was, her relationship with…