This week on Take Me In to the Ballgame:

Ellen Adair and Eric Gilde discuss the 1974 Roy Campanella biopic, “It’s Good to Be Alive,” rating this TV movie on the 20-80 scouting scale. They introduce the episode (1:19), with an overview of the story, cast, and expectations coming into the film. After a description of the 20-80 scouting grades for those who are unfamiliar (8:37), they begin with Amount of Baseball (10:12), discussing how to bring something up to code to be considered a baseball movie. Eric makes some claims about the scouting scale. No spoilers on the player comp! Baseball Accuracy (14:51) includes an Ellen Adair Breakdown on Campanella’s hands and injury history, along with details of the car accident and initial expectations afterwards, Campy’s thoughts about L.A., Ruthe’s visits, Campy’s salary and Walter O’Malley, and a compare and contrast of his real speech vs. the film speech. Storytelling (36:22) examines the usage of flashbacks, both good (a childhood scene about his biracial identity) and bad (a very puzzling scene with his son David). Discussion of the difficulties of Roy adjusting to his new life, Campy as a coach and manager, and the annoying reporter, with shout-out to Jason Vargas. Praise for the fly scene, and speculation about what Ruthe is drinking. They discuss the Score (1:03:17) and Acting (1:04:50), particularly Paul Winfield, Ruby Dee, and Louis Gossett, Jr. Ellen has a rundown of three specific excellent choices by Ruby Dee. Delightfulness of Catcher (1:10:45) is a fun tool to score for this film, with conversation about real Roy vs. his film depiction, some highlights of his real-life catching career, and mentioning early interest in him from the Phillies and Pirates. Ellen is not able to resist mentioning J.T. Realmuto, but just once. Delightfulness of Announcer (1:17:30) and Lack of Misogyny (1:18:11) follow, the latter considering that the film was written from Roy’s point of view. Eric brings up some of the questions about the timeline on the night of Campanella’s accident. Yes or No (1:25:16) briefly addresses Jackie Robinson and Satchel Paige easter eggs in the film, along with the Classic Questions. No spoilers on the following segments: Six Degrees of Baseball (1:29:42), Favorite Moment (1:31:34) Least Favorite Moment (1:33:28), Scene We Would Have Liked to See (1:34:25), Dreamiest Player (1:38:14), Favorite Performance (1:39:23), Next Time (1:42:33), and Review Thank You (1:44:14).

 

Don’t miss an episode –Subscribe Apple Podcasts or Subscribe to our Newsletter

 

Eric Gilde and Ellen Adair

Share
Published by
Eric Gilde and Ellen Adair

Recent Posts

New Year, New Team

On this episode of the Caught em Looking podcast, we catch up on all the…

2 days ago

S2E13 Playbook For The Portal

In this episode of the Mental Health Playbook, Coach Trav reflects on the new year,…

2 days ago

Episode 272: Wildcard Weekend 26′

The Underdog NFL Show opens the postseason with coaching shockwaves, including John Harbaugh’s firing, draft…

3 days ago

S10E20: NFL Playoffs, College Football Semi’s, and More

On this week’s episode the boys return for 2026 and are greeted with playoff games…

3 days ago

Episode 451: CFB Semis, NFL Playoffs, and Traitors is Back!

The Underdog opens with a deep dive into The Traitors Season 4 before shifting to…

3 days ago

Ep. 245: Looking Back at ’25, Analytics with Eno Sarris

On this week’s episode of Long Gone, we’re thankful to kick off Season 6 by…

4 days ago

This website uses cookies.