As Gary Thibodeau awaited trial for the kidnapping and presumed murder of Heidi Allen, rumors about what really happened to Heidi began to surface. In February of 1995, the FBI questioned a man who ran up and down Green Road, in Mexico, New York, yelling he had information about Heidi’s kidnapping. That man told the FBI that Heidi was wrapped up in drugs, and she was abducted and murdered to prevent her from disclosing information about a drug ring in Oswego County. Bt police and prosecutor Donald Dodd already said Heidi was never used as a drug informant, and there was no evidence that the Thibodeau’s were ever involved in selling drugs. Even though two men were charged with Heidi’s kidnapping there were still many unanswered questions, and as time went on it more even more questions began popping up.