Episode 10: The Dump
The prosecutor withheld critical information that would help Gary Thibodeau prove his innocence. Yet, he claimed time and time again all he wanted was to find the truth.
The prosecutor withheld critical information that would help Gary Thibodeau prove his innocence. Yet, he claimed time and time again all he wanted was to find the truth.
The Oswego County Sheriff’s exposed Heidi Allen’s identity as a confidential drug informant when she was just a teenager. Could this be why she was taken?
Thibodeau’s defense team and a reporter found a cabin in the woods where three cadaver dogs picked up the scent of human remains. Which seemed to corroborate what Priest told police.
Tonya priest wasn’t James Steen’s only confessor, Megan Shaw told sheriff’s investigators Steen bragged about disposing of Heidi’s body.
For the first time since Heidi went missing a witness said she knew where Heidi was taken after being abducted on Easter morning in 1994. This was the first time anyone has ever said publicly they knew where Heidi was taken after being abducted
There was a man openly walking the streets of Oswego with a violent past, and a motive to kidnap Heidi Allen. His name was not Gary Thibodeau.
Two trials, the same evidence, one brother guilty, one brother acquitted. One conviction and still no answers about what happened to Heidi Allen.
As Gary Thibodeau awaited trial for the kidnapping and presumed murder of Heidi Allen, rumors about what really happened to Heidi began to surface. In February of 1995, the FBI questioned a man who ran up and down Green Road, in Mexico, New York, yelling he had information about Heidi […]
Gary Thibodeau was awaiting trial and even though police were getting no closer to finding Heidi it seemed like the only thing that mattered was that someone be punished for her kidnapping.